Tuesday, 11 November 2014

Post-digital provocations #3: 'in response to' the digital

In the previous two posts I talked about the digital 'mode of knowledge production' and the kinds of change it has brought about in educational relationships and practice. I argued that changes to the contexts of learning affect learners' relationships to their institutions and to each other and to us as educators. That changes in theory and method in academic practice, and in the content of curricula and in what is expected of graduates, are all influencing how we come to know things and to value what we know. I summarised these changes as generally making knowledge more fluid, and situations of learning more porous or 'leaky'. And I considered how traces of learning and development are easier to make and more persistent, both in the kind of records that learners make themselves and in the data trails that organisations (educational and commercial) make of them. A recent Times Higher article, for example, shows that academics and students alike are waking up to the implications of learner analytics for the relationships between students and institutions.

There are changes that I think time has shown to be less profound. The interactivity of digital media would for me be one, or the different terms used for independent learning when digital technologies are involved, though these have at various moments in the digital 'wave' seemed essential to its forward momentum. In my slides I also cautioned against substituting developments in digital technologies for political engagement with issues of equality and power, in the belief that entities such as 'the internet' or practices such as 'open sharing' necessarily entail more equal access to learning opportunity or more democratic institutions.

In this post I want to consider our response to digital transformations, and to do that in two moods, though I don't see them as distinct. One is an intellectual response or critique, and  the other is a felt response to the experience of living/teaching/learning in a world saturated with digital technologies. I wasn't originally planning to bring the second kind of response so fully into view, but a recent keynote by Audrey Watters at the ALT conference, followed by a seminar with Bonnie Stewart as part of the #scholar14 MOOC, have convinced me that it is necessary. That is, we must acknowledge our own feelings including fear, vulnerability, boredom and compulsion in relation to digital technology if we are to support students and staff in the same space. We must practice rigorous critique of the technologies we are offered to use, but also speak from our consciences and hearts, especially when we experience digital spaces being colonised by values that are antithetical to educational (and human) development.

My second set of slides is now available on slideshare. In the following slide I am wondering aloud what it feels like to think/act/be in online spaces that are simultaneously private and public, that are porous in ways we might not feel we have consented to. There is no one response, and one of the points I am making is that this feels very different depending on whether you are a man or a woman, from the global north or south, digitally and/or educationally empowered or not, and in other very personal ways.

For each of these there are negative feelings associated with either end of the axis. There is of course a middle ground where we are thoughtful, balanced, in control of our relationship with technology. Where I might feel (for example) neither fearful of interacting online, nor liable to behave disrespectfully to others. However, increasingly I seem to be able to experience both negative ends of the spectrum at the same time. In writing this keynote, for example, I am working obsessively on my slides, using Keynote and Google advanced image search, and cycling between them like my daughter's hamster on its little mouse wheel. I've just noticed that it's after midnight and I probably haven't got up from the laptop in three hours. At the same time I feel ungrounded and dispersed through the various media I am using and through the different sources I have open. I am slightly in despair at the impossible task of keeping up with all the exciting people who are blogging in this area (see my blogs to watch on the right). I also feel some guilt that I am dipping into various online discussions in order to snatch at what is useful to me immediately, rather than making my own stance visible or committing to participate over time.

I have hardly made myself vulnerable through this confession and I feel lucky that I participate online as regularly as I do without (yet) meeting with any significant abuse or trolling. But I see that many many women do experience this, from below the line responses to female columnists such as Hadley Freeman in the Guardian, to the reaction Audrey Watter received when she posted that 'Gamergate is an EdTech issue' on Hack Education. And in similar vein I understand that participating online, especially in academic spaces, feels very different if you are not English, not from the global North, not from an elite institution such as most UK universities (in a global context) are, not from a particular educational culture, not physically able, not digitally able, not a 'proper' student, (not a 'proper' academic)... Maha Bali's blog is an upbeat but sobering read on many of these issues.

So, as Bonnie Stewart has argued, we need to take care of each other in digital spaces, recognising that they engender vulnerabilities as well as opportunities. How much truer that is when the others are our students. In my final provocation tomorrow I will ask how we might recover from digital fall-out, and help our students to recover too, in ways that make us all more resilient.


ICD pk said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Me Myself and I said...

Helen, this is an enlightening post. I see so many feelings I share in it. How can we educate others (young and old) when we ourselves feel not in control?

Worse is the struggle within, where I would like to take full benefit from technology, but at the same moment hesitate to not being dependent, exposed, vulnerable, etc.

Sanjay Agrawal said...

gate coaching centres
gate coaching classes
gate coaching for mechanical engineering
gate coaching for computer science
gate training institutes

Anonymous said...

Understanding a few key considerations when designing banner stands can help businesses find the perfect final design solution for their needs. Read on to learn more about this topic.
Design dine egne banner, RudkĂžbing

GateIIT Coaching said...

gate biotechnology coaching centres
gate coaching for chemical engineering
gate coaching for civil engineering
ies coaching centers
iit jee coaching institutes
gate coaching for aerospace engineering

williamson said...


Global Incorporate involves researched and knowledgeable infromation which enhaces the facts of Digital Marketing. It highlights on the key aspects of the Digital World together with SEO and Social Media Strategies.

Vinay Chandel said...

Informative share on digital marketing. There are many ecommerce website development company India offering best development services with digital marketing strategies. Since to choice best one is more beneficial for development need.

Sankar lp said...

I am technology Enthusiast. Your blog is really awesome, attractive and impressive. I like the way you think. it is very useful for Java SE & Java EE Learners. Your article adds best knowledge to our Java Online Training from India. or learn thru Java Online Training from India Students. or learn thru JavaScript Online Training from India. Appreciating the persistence you put into your blog and detailed information you provide. Kindly keep blogging.

snitch media said...

Nice post if you want more information regarding webdesign
webdesign & development in hyderabad

Rashmi Chaudhary said...

Really i found this article more informative, thanks for sharing this article.
website designing company in gurgaon

sandy p said...

good information and very use full for every one BOXFinity a Web designing company in Hyderabad creates websites with creative & professional approach. whatever your website is ?static ?dynamic ?responsive.

Deepthi Chowdary said...

Hi Nice Post,For More Updates

webdesign & development

Priyanka said...

Thanks for sharing."
"Very very informative article and clearly understandable.
Advertising Agency in Hyderabad

123456 said...

veri nice article. if you aguys are looking for advertising agencies in bangalore, please connect tempest advertising.
leading advertising agency in bangalore
advertising agency in bangalore
best advertising agency in bangalore
top advertising agency in bangalore
bangalore advertising

Ajay said...

life is about learning by the base of concept we provide studela. for the learning people it is very useful one. In studela we provide a video for maths coaching, science projects,bank exam, IAS exam,TNPSC group exam,RRB exam, other compatative exam, kids learning videos and some technology videos are availabe. watch more videos get your view smart