Thursday 17 September 2015

Conference reflections: digital work and political futures

This was meant to be my reflections on last week's ALT conference: Shaping the Future of Learning Together, but like many people I know I've been distracted by the outcome of another conference, the Labour Party Special Conference to announce the winner of its leadership contest. My twitter stream has been a double-stranded flow of excitement about digital and political futures, with not much exchange between them. Some friends have even suggested that it would be good for me - and my twitter followers - if I kept my political views running in a separate channel to my work on digital literacies and digital education.

But it's hard not to notice how many people in the world of e-learning are dipping into the Corbyn stream. Hard not to be excited - if you care about education - that we have a Leader of the Opposition who wants to reintroduce student grants, who promises to reverse this Government's savage cuts to FE and adult/skills, and who views education as a 'collective good' that demands investment and safeguarding through a lifelong 'national education service'. Whether or not Jeremy Corbyn can deliver on these promises, debates that we thought were dead and buried are coming back to life in front of our eyes.

And the unexpectedness of Corbyn's win, the loss of any certainty about how electors will respond to continued austerity at home and war/misery/emigration overseas, the questioning of apparently unshakeable economic verities by serious economists as well as climate change and anti-capitalist protestors - these should make us all very nervous of current 'futures thinking', or at least the kind that talks up the 'digital economy' as though we know exactly what that means. It might mean the dog-eat-dog of neo-liberal entrepreneurialism, or the 'sharing economy' that would have us monetise every skill we gain, every interest we entertain, and all the space in our homes and cars we aren't actually using to breathe in. It might look like the mechanical turk writ large, with human brain space rented out to projects determined by the demands of data. Or it might look like old-fashioned collectivism with the emphasis on digital participation and decision making. It might look like a lot of paid and unpaid work in caring for others, with the help of personal data services, the digital world a beautiful collaborative playground where we spend much of the leisure time we have on our hands. It might look like a world of infinitely permeable borders, or one of constant surveillance and control, or most likely both at once. We know it will be digital, or 'post-digital' if you must, but beyond that there's still everything to play for.

So perhaps I am working and thinking in a space where digital and political futures are intertwined. At the moment I'd call this space 'the changing world of work', and mean by that both the lived experience of working inside UK HE and FE, and the 'world of work' as reified in current education policy - as the entire rationale and telos of our students' learning, the 'real' against which our intellectual and pedagogical labour must finally be reckoned.

This year I have mainly been working on a project called Framing the Digital Capabilities of Staff in UK HE and FE. The project was funded by Jisc who will be publishing my report and other deliverables shortly. I've already used this work to inform a revised Digital Capabilities Framework which I hope will be useful to people working in this space. What I have to say here is in no way endorsed by Jisc and it arises from only a small area of my work for them - my review of the changing nature of work inside and outside the academy. I was lucky enough to talk with more than 60 professionals in HE and FE about their work and the role digital technology plays in it, and their thoughts have certainly informed my own. But the interviews ranged widely and none of the people I spoke to would necessarily draw the same conclusions that I do. With that important disclaimer, here are my thoughts on...

The changing world of work


Some people I know, looking as if they are working (CC Jisc 2014)

Many excellent researchers have studied work inside academic organisations: I have been particularly influenced by Lynne Gornall and her co-editors of Academic Working Lives (2014). Go read it if you want to know more. (This and all my other references can be found online here along with key stats, facts and quotes). According to this and other sources, academic and professional work is becoming:

  • less secure – rise of short-term contracts, constant restructuring, funding constraints;
  • shorter term – defined by short/medium term initiatives, often organised in flexible project teams (e.g. task and finish);
  • more goal-driven – KPIs, personal performance management, citation index, REF, NSS, teaching quality measures, service level agreements;
  • uncertainly located – open offices, hot desking, working from home, working across multiple campuses, working online;
  • more self-directed – rise of self-employment, consultancy, project-based working and enterpreneurship; also the individual's responsibility to constantly improve (the self as project);
  • multiple/hybrid – people doing more than one job (split contracts), roles crossing professions or specialisms;
  • technology-based – core processes carried out within institutional IT systems, some aspects entirely automated, rise in roles with IT-related responsibilities e.g. in learning technology, organisational data (NB this list is my summary of multiple sources).
Of course not all of these changes can be associated directly with the impact of digital technologies in education. They have arisen in a political context of constrained finances, increased competition for students and commodification of the student experience, an interest in the quantification of outcomes, and the favouring of managerial over collegial modes of governance. However, digital technologies have played a role both instrumentally - enabling governments and organisations to carry through some of these agendas - and also contextually, for example supporting the development of cheaper alternatives against which the 'value' of traditional courses is now to be measured.

Employability and the 'world of work' also penetrate every aspect of the student experience via part-time work, work placements, internships, sponsorships, and co-curricular activities reframed as tokens of employability. Employment is widely seen as making sense and ascribing value to the whole experience of education. And this wider world of work is also changing in comparable ways. It is becoming:

  • less secure, with multiple job and career changes and the rise of casual, part-time, informal and self-employment;
  • more entrepreneurial, via the 'gig' or 'sharing' economy (uber, AMT, clickworker, workfusion, mechanical turk) on the one hand, and on the other the rise of project-based working teams and internal marketisation (intrapreneurship) within relatively secure forms of employment;
  • fragmented in terms of attention, tasks, work-time and work-space, working teams;
  • multiple and hybrid, with simultaneous contracts/roles/projects/commitments in work and the monetisation of previously private pursuits, hobbies, personal time and space;
  • uncertainly located through disclocation from the traditional workplace and a rise in home working;
  • automated and/or at risk from automation, with up to 36% UK jobs likely to be lost in next 20 years; cognitive work is being done by a smaller number of people working collaboratively with IT and data systems.

Key career assets are now a person's immediately relevant capabilities, rather than (say) length of service, and these must be constantly updated, especially where digital technologies are concerned. So digital capabilities are essential to finding and retaining work and to managing multiple work roles. This is equally true of staff as it is of the students who are being supported to enhance their employability. 

Many people, perhaps especially women, find the flexibility of digital work a liberation. This has certainly been my own experience as a long-time single mother. I've also been lucky enough to work with many educators who are inspired by digital opportunities for learning and have shared that inspiration with their students. Across disciplines, digital technology is both an exciting new subject of scholarship and a whole new toolbox for discovery, exploration and the communication of ideas. But aspects of digital academic work cause frustration and stress. Staff worry about keeping 'up to date' (the self as project again), about growing demands on their time and attention, about information overload and the loss of boundaries between work and home. People who went into teaching because they preferred face-to-face contact with students to life in the archive or laboratory find they spend most of their time sitting at a screen.

Students too worry about the loss of face-to-face contact time, but perhaps more acutely about their own working futures. For a majority of graduates, the 'digital economy' has not meant high-value 'knowledge' work but white-collar labour in call centres and data departments, insecure self-employment, or piecemeal work in a hybrid (human/computer) service economy. Most graduates are exercising their entrepreneurialism to find, retain and stitch together opportunities to earn, rather than leading digital start-ups. Dougald Hine has spoken powerfully about the new graduate 'precariat', who have 'done everything right' but are still struggling to find meaningful work. And whatever their work, it is likely to take place in a largely digital setting, which brings its own stresses - cyberbullying, information overload, repetitive strain and other health risks, loss of face-to-face relationships - as well as new opportunities and new networks of support.

This precariat, and the young people on the brink of entering it, are significant among the people who have elected Jeremy Corbyn to lead the Labour Party. (If his detractors are to be believed, the rest are 'intellectuals', which puts education professionals squarely in the frame as well.)

Our relationship with 'work' as educators
Students Hold Up a Sign that Says "Free Education."
CC Michael Fleshman: http://www.tikkun.org/nextgen/neoliberalisms-war-against-the-radical-imagination

At this point I want to suggest that we have a responsibility, as educators, to involve ourselves in what it means to work in a digital age. This is true both of our own work and the work for which we are preparing our students. So far from being removed from the pressures acting on the wider economy, educators are in some ways in the vanguard (or firing line). Our work is quintessentially 'knowledge' work. Our workplaces are among the most hybrid (real/virtual) in the world, as I have argued recently in Lea's Enhancing Learning and Teaching in HE. Rightly or wrongly, a 'passion' for our subject has long been held up as the defining quality of a lecturer, which makes us in some ways the archetype of the 'passionate' amateur who is C21st capitalism's fantasy worker. Unless we understand ourselves as particular kinds of worker - and producer - in the C21st economy, we risk being disempowered in relation to our own working lives, and failing to theorise and organise on our own behalf, let alone on behalf of others who are caught up in the same nexus of forces.

As far as our students are concerned, the employability agenda has for too long been handed down into the curriculum as a given, rather than opened up within the curriculum as a set of questions about what it means to be productive in a C21st society: what value particular subject areas bring to the defining challenges of our times, what it means to live (and work) well, and how work might best be organised. As well as enabling students to cope with their immediate economic realities, it is also our place to develop critical people who can question the technologies and technology-based roles they are offered, and find new solutions to the conundrum of how to work and live in a digital society.

There has been important work around the idea of students-as-producers of knowledge, for example at the University of Lincoln and behind the NUS' Manifesto for Partnership. As educators we can support that work through our teaching and curriculum practices. But we can also support it by putting our own working lives under a critical lens. Over the last decade the 'students as consumers' narrative has reframed our work as service provision to learning consumers and - more importantly - to their future employers through students as agents of productivity. Research has been obsessively quantified for its impact on measurable outcomes, ideally transferable into monetary terms. The fetish for quantity has obscured some of the qualities that really matter in educational work, such as the quality of relationships in a community of knowledge and understanding, or the quality of the relationship between teachers and students. 

Jonathan Worth’s keynote at Alt-C returned us to that relationship. He spoke about the vulnerability of learners, the trust they place in us, and the attention we must pay constantly to the workings of power in teaching/learning as in other close human engagements (photographer/subject, seer/seen, designer/user). He also alerted us to the changes of meaning and the altered nuances of power when these relationships are mediated online. Hidden in his talk I felt were some deep questions about the nature of professional work - photography, teaching, design - when technology equips and then exhorts people to 'do it themselves'. Whether taking selfies or taking part in self-directed learning, we are dispensing with a whole class of relationships with more capable others, or defining them as a supplement - a premium service - instead of a critical term in what was once a relational activity. To 'work' as an educator increasingly means to facilitate learners' engagements with various systems within which their identities, their knowledge and their capabilities are distributed, and not to engage with them in a relationship of concern for who they are becoming.

Laura's keynote, Inequality in Higher Education, offered us a wide-ranging interrogation of learning technology through the lens of social justice. She showed us how the question of what kind of society we want to live in is continually posed and (partially) answered by the work we do as educators. To give an example with which Laura and I have both been involved, we can ask how our work as open educators impacts on the distribution of educational opportunity. When we ask that question we quickly realise that open is not enough - that the wealth of new opportunities to learn are being taken up overwhelmingly by people who are already well resourced and well motivated. Where there is systemic inequality only systemic redress - organised investment in those who have been disadvantaged - can change the balance. Laura reminds us that while our day-to-day work rightly focuses on helping individuals to meet their aspirations, in the long view we are also helping to build a world in which everyone can thrive. She reminds us that education is care, and that care costs.

Whether our work as educators moves in the direction of social justice and human wellbeing is not something we can fully determine as individuals. Our actions are constrained by political and economic - and nowadays by associated technical - systems. But those contexts change, sometimes in extraordinary ways. The Corbyn train arrives, unannounced. Endlessly-announced transformations fail to arrive (see David Kernohan's brilliant recent post on the e-learning hype industry) or when they do arrive fail to take anyone where they want to go. There is nothing inevitable about how work will be organised ten or twenty years from now - that is for political action to determine. In how our work as educators is valued, the victory of quantity over quality is not pre-determined either. There is always hope. It's all to play for.

62 comments:

Frances Bell said...

Thanks for this great post Helen. All disciplines tend to silos and Ed Tech is no exception. It was no surprise to me that one of the authors of the Mechanical Turk was Debra Howcroft, an ex-colleague from the Information Systems Institute, now subsumed in at Salford Business School. In Information Systems there has been a healthy tradition of critique, particularly of the technological determinism that crops up in 'e-learning strategies' , popular articles and, sad to say, some ed tech research.
While I was reading your post, I found myself linking the resurgence of interest in politics represented by the JC effect to digital literacies, about which you have written much. Like you I think it's all to play for, and it gives me hope that educators and students will be challenging the Googles, the Facebooks as well as institutional tech systems. When I was teaching Masters students, the discussion session critiquing Turnitin from perspectives of ethics and power as well business was always a lovely one and helped students to turn their gaze on the tech they took as a given. It is possible to treat Facebook as a subject in education without forcing students to use it as an edupunk VLE. A group of us found it possible embed critical digital literacies in the ug curriculum and though students learned over time to be critical about some SNS they were just as entranced by shiny stuff as the rest of us.

Czernie said...

Thanks for the thoughtful weaving together of these threads Helen.....then there is this...http://www.thenation.com/article/this-is-how-bad-the-sharing-economy-is-for-workers/

addirigib said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Unknown said...

Well said. Teaching method is changing over time. Most schools adopt for E learning. Students took help from web to complete their academic works. They are downloading books from internet and searching for contents for assignments etc. Internet made students life easy. They get help from admission essay writing service to complete their essay works.

BestKeptself said...

It’s difficult to find well-informed people about this topic, however, you seem like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks
www.bestkeptself.com

Anonymous said...


You're a new coach, fresh out of a reputable coach-training program and ready to start your career. But as excited as you are about
embarking on your new life's journey, one thing's standing in the way: promoting and marketing your coaching services.
The mere thought fills you with dread; you don't know what to do, or where to begin.
If you need help on this matter please take a peek at-Systemisches coaching

George Mark said...

Really Nice facts & Stuff Thanks for guide us show the right path.
You may also follow the Work From Home jobs in Australia

Unknown said...

Buzz App

Gerald said...

Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful! I've been looking for books of this nature for a way too long. I'm just glad that I found yours. Looking forward for your next post.



I found the best Leviton Receptacle

Unknown said...

Becoming a freelancing web designer and working from your home office is a career many would like to pursue. Find out what it takes to become a successful freelancer in this dynamic and ever-changing field.
see more details:SEO company Massachusetts

Unknown said...

Good work…unique site and interesting too… keep it up…looking forward for more updates.Good luck to all of you and thanks so much for your hard-work.
Transcription Services in Bangalore, Closed Captioning Services in Bangalore,Localization And Translation Services

Joanna Kuligowska said...

Hi. Have you heard about the company Home Expert? They have really great furniture and stuff for your kitchen and bathroom. Just visit their main page ;)

Unknown said...

Web Pixel World's Online Examination Management Software can manage all of your work to conduct online examination.
Web Pixel World web designing & development company in Dehradun free online training in web pixel world.

reCAPTCHA V1 IS SHUTDOWN

Vistas AD Media said...

Thanks for the post
Web Pixel World web designing & development company in Bangalore free online training in web pixel world.

Marysia said...


I think what you are writing about, ie digital work is the future!
I recently invested in an ERP system to make power more and faster. I think it was a great deism.
Everything improves this system very much. Now I'm thinking about axapta - Anegis

Marysia said...


I think so too. I'm also going digital.
Now I'm investing in cloud solutions - I think it's great!
It's really improving everything.
I recommend reading about it more

Unknown said...

Great post man.. seriously this is the best post i have ever came across.. thank you so much for wonderful share.

Unknown said...

I think this is the best info I have ever seen today.. Thanks to you my friend...
http://www.gilltom.com/technology/how-microsoft-is-ruling-the-cloud/

123456 said...

veri nice article. if you aguys are looking for advertising agencies in bangalore, please connect tempest advertising.
leading advertising agency in bangalore
advertising agency in bangalore
best advertising agency in bangalore
top advertising agency in bangalore
bangalore advertising

stephen said...

Thanks for sharing nice information with us. i like your post and all you share with us is uptodate and quite informative, i would like to bookmark the page so i can come here again to read you, as you have done a wonderful job. Website Los Angeles

abhishek said...

thanks for sharing this information

royaldeveloper

SEO Company in Rishikesh
SEO in Rishikesh
SEO Services in Rishikesh


The Poly kids said...

Jyotish Services in Dehradun
Jyotish Kendra in Dehradun
Astrologer In Dehradun
Famous Astrologers in Dehradun
Top Astrologers in Dehradun

Tree Multisoft Services said...

I know that you put much attention for these articles, as all of them make sense and are very useful.
we are the leading Bulk SMS service Provider in Maharastra,
we provide the best Bulk SMS Kerala,
We provide the bestBulk SMS in Uttarakhand,
we are the leading Bulk SMS Provider in Dehradun,
we are the leading Bulk SMS Provider in Madhya Pradesh

Tree Multisoft Services said...

Treemultisoft is the best Website Designing company in Dehradun. We offer wide range of web services like Software Development Company in Dehradun, graphic Design Dehradun, Mobile app Development company in Dehradun, SEO Company in Dehradun , website Development company in Dehradun

Bajrangi yoga said...

thanks for sharing this information
great post !

100 Hour Yoga TTC in Rishikesh
100 Hour Yoga Teacher Training in Rishikesh
100 Hour Yoga Teacher Training Course in Rishikesh

Manish said...

Thank you for sharing such great information very useful to us.

hotels tungnath
hotels at chamoli
hotels in chamoli
hotels in chamoli gopeshwar
hotels in chamoli uttarakhand
best Hotels in Chamoli
resorts in chamoli
best resorts in chamoli
places to stay in chamoli
Cheapest hotel in chamoli
hotels in chamoli
hotels at chamoli

Manish said...

Bond cleaning Brisbane
Bond cleaning services Brisbane
Cheap bond cleaning brisbane
Bond cleaning Brisbane Northside
Bond cleaning Brisbane Southside
Exit Cleaning Brisbane
End of lease Cleaning Brisbane
Vacate Cleaning Brisbane
Bond back Cleaning Brisbane

Mahi said...

Wow, great post! I just want to leave my super-thoughtful comment here for you to read. I've made it thought-provoking and insightful, and also questioned some to the points you made in your blog post to keep you on your toes...
Thanks...
Regards
Website Designing Company Dehradun

Uttrakhand Taxi Services said...

very nice post. Thank you

Anonymous said...

If you are looking for best Biker rental service in Dehradun then www.ghoomakad.co.in.

stark said...

Hii Great Information for us,
Best Website Desigining & Development in Roorkee
Best PHP Training in Roorkee

sheikh said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Aditi Sharma said...

Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article. We are top CRM Software | CRM Software Mumbai | CRM Software Provider | CRM Software Pune | Field Management Software | CRM Software India

abhishek said...

Thanks a lot this information is very very useful
i am very Happy.

SEO company in Rishikesh
Web designing in Rishikesh
Seo in Rishikesh
Web development company in Rishikesh
Website development company in Rishikesh

Unknown said...

1.Website Development in Haridwar
2.Website Designing in Haridwar
3.PHP Training in Roorkee
4.Website Development in Roorkee
5.Website Designing in Roorkee
6.Website Softwere in Roorkee
7.Website Softwere in Haridwar
8.Website Development in Dehradun
9.Website Designing in Dehradun
10.Website Softwere in Dehradun
11. School Management System in roorkee
12. . School Management System in Haridwar
13. . School Management System in Dehradun
14. Coaching Management System in roorkee
15.Coaching Management System in Haridwar
16.Coaching Management System in Dehradun
17. Online Examination System in roorkee
18.Online Examination System in Haridwar
19.Online Examination System in Dehradun
20.Website Development Company in Haridwar
21.Website Designing Company in Haridwar

IDesignPassion said...

Thank you so much for sharing article with us. It seems very informative. Please keep sharing.

Web Design Firms Chicago
Best Chicago Web Design Agency

seoheights said...

Thank you for sharing valuable post with us. It seems very informative for all readers.
Thank you.
Seoheights
Best SEO Company
SEO Company in Toronto

akshay said...

Thank you for every other excellent article. Where else may anybody get
that type of information in such an ideal means of
writing? I have a presentation subsequent week, and I’m at the look for such information.
:) :D:D

Anonymous said...

Nice blog keep going..
Digital Marketing | Outsource SEO Services | Digital Marketing Services | Digital Marketing in India

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing Information.
Legal Abstraction In Bangalore
Multilingual Lease Abstraction In Bangalore
Localization
Translation Agency In Delhi

Haritha Yogshala said...

I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have bookmarked you to check out new stuff you post.
yoga teacher training in India
200 Hour Yoga Teacher Training in Rishikesh
Ayurveda in Rishikesh

Mr Rahman said...

Really Nice & Very helpful Post
Website Design & Development Company In Dehradun

wordpar29 said...

Your blog is very nice and we hope you are providing more information in future times.
E-learning Localization Usa|E Learning Localization Services Usa|E Learning Localization Services In Usa|E Learning Localization Europe|E Learning Localization Services Europe

Welcome TO Yoga Essence said...

thanks for share latest article. its very helpful for me Meditation Teacher Training India

Wordpar said...

I am very happy when I read this blog post because it is written in a good manner and writes on a good topic. Thanks for sharing valuable information.
Indian Languages Translator | Translation Company In India | E-learning Localization | Voice-over Services

Lain Lab said...

The Best Language-Learning Software for 2020. Do you want to buy a laboratory software? Find out how our language learning software can help your or your school, library or business. Lain Lab offer multimedia language lab software equipment for student benefit and training.

Rahul said...

Fully Access Group SEO Tool Just Rs 299/-*

AlisaJankovic said...

Do you want to be a yoga trainer/teacher? Do you have a dream to start your yoga organization? Well, if you have such dreams and desires, then it is highly recommended to join a reputed yoga teacher training course in bangalore. They also offer customized yoga classed to help people get fit physically, mentally, and spiritually and reach their fitness goals. Don’t believe me? Try out. Looking forward to your next post. Cheers!

wayne said...

This Article is Enough Good to Understand and quite interesting .Thanks For Sharing Such a Informative Content here

Visit this great website!

Welcome TO Yoga Essence said...

amazing post . meditation ashram india

Acadestudio said...

Nice blog...

Multimedia Localization Services

jerry miller said...

Thanks for the post very nice

Link Doozer said...

Very efficiently written information. It will be valuable to everyone who uses it, including myself. Thanks.
I can say this is the best way to know gain knowledge thank You!!
Regards

WEB DEVELOPMENT Company in Dehradun

Gyanas said...

Enjoyed a lot while reading this amazing article this was very informative & knowledgeable content on this blog thanx for sharing such an amazing article. Web Designing Services in Dehradun

Kashika said...

Thanks a lot for such informative blog. Visit Here for NDA Foundation Course in Dehradun!

jerry miller said...

Extremely interesting. Thank you for giving such an informative blog.

jerry miller said...

Great resource and a very interesting to read. Great work.

jerry miller said...


thank you so much for sharing. this is so important to me and a great help for others.

Dream Zone said...

graphic design training in dehradun
Being a reputed graphics design institute in Dehradun, our courses encompass typography & sort design, publication design, image creation, illustration, photography, packing, print design, corporate individuality, branding, information & communication elements in digital sphere as well as correspondents medium.
Our foremost objective is to arouse the evolution of independent critical decision-making, refined research skills, the capability to think creatively and practice design like a pro.

trendy answers said...

This article is very helpful, I wondered about this amazing article.. This is very informative.
“you are doing a great job, and give us up to dated information”.
Skip Hire Plymouth

nda coaching in chandigarh said...

Chandigarh Career Group best NDA Coaching Institute in Chandigarh. If you aim to join the Indian Army immediately after the 12th and want to grow as an army officer,
clearing the NDA entrance exam is the initial step. We provide the Best NDA Coaching in Chandigarh to make your dream from vision to reality.
We strive to fulfill the dreams of our students by offering the desired learning.
And provide the most effective NDA Coaching in Chandigarh as we have the most qualified faculty with teaching experience of many years.
With an over 81% achievement record in NDA entrance, we provide an exceptional amongst the NDA Coaching in Chandigarh and CDS Coaching in Chandigarh.

Arman Nair said...

I was an extremely informative and helpful article.
Web Designing company in Dehradun
Best Website development company in Dehradun
graphic Designer in Dehradun
Digital Marketing in Dehradun
Mobile app Development company in Dehradun